U.S. Government Shutdown

To my friends abroad who have queried about the U.S. government shutdown and debt limit crisis. You have rightly heard that the odd thing about this crisis is that it is not based on U.S. economic conditions, which are fine and quite capable of keeping the government running and paying its bills, but is a crisis that is entirely unnecessary and manufactured by political choice.

The Republican position is that unless the Democrats make some policy concessions, they won’t release the money to keep the government running, nor do they want to raise the debt limit so the government can pay its bills. They believe that the Democrats should be willing to negotiate on this.

The Democratic position is that this is extortion, not negotiation. Negotiation is “you give me something I want and I’ll give you something you want”; extortion is “give me what I want or I’ll do something destructive that no one wants – I’ll wreck the economy.”

To view through the oft-used household analogy, Democrats are saying that it’s legitimate for spouses to negotiate at the time of any major purchase. But once purchases are made, it’s not legitimate for one spouse to say, “Meet my present demands or I’ll close down our business (i.e., shutter the government) and refuse to pay all our credit card bills that are due next week (the debt limit issue).” The second case, to the Democrats, is more like extortion than negotiation. And they feel compelled to hold this line, on the grounds that a recurring strategy of “meet my demands or I’ll blow up the economy” cannot be tolerated as a sustainable model of governance.

Or to paraphrase one Democratic Congresswoman: “Health care policy should be negotiable. Social security and tax reform should be negotiable. Whether we can be trusted to keep the government open and pay our bills should not be negotiable.”

3 thoughts on “U.S. Government Shutdown

  1. True that a responsible spouse should pay the credit card debts of the marriage. However the fiscally responsible spouse (in this case the Republican party) should then cancel the card.
    Washington is drunk on deficit spending. NEVER in written history has a nation survived printing fiat currency.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.